Where to Find Grass-fed Butter

find grass-fed butter

Want to know where to find grass-fed butter? I’ve said before that butter is a health food, but grass-fed butter is even better — a nutritional powerhouse of vitamins A, D, & K-2, heart-disease preventing CLA (conjugated linoleic acid), and so much more.

Yet finding grass-fed butter can be hard for those newly committed to doing so. Is buying certified organic butter enough? Do you absolutely need to find a local pasture-based dairy? What if there are no pasture-based dairies near you?

Consider this your guide for where to find grass fed butter.


Find Grass-Fed Butter Locally: Best Choice

Optimally, you’ll be able to find a pasture-based dairy near you and buy directly from the farmer. There are several ways of doing this:

1. Use the Real Milk Finder at RealMilk.com.

Note that not every dairy local to you will be listed. Since raw milk sales are controversial, many farmers may opt to protect their privacy by NOT being listed in the directory. Also, many dairies only produce milk and do not process it into options like butter or cheese. In those cases, you’ll simply have to know how to make butter from cream.

2. Contact your local Weston A Price chapter leader.

Because the Weston A Price Foundation is a strong advocate for raw milk from grass-fed cows, your local chapter leader will probably know of just about every available local source. Don’t be afraid to give them a call. They don’t bite!

3. Visit your local farmer’s market.

Even in states that don’t allow off-farm sales of raw, grass-fed milk, you will often find those dairies represented at your local farmer’s markets. They won’t be selling their raw milk at the market, but they may sell everything else, including lightly pasteurized milk, butter, cheese, cheese spreads, sour cream, cream, and more — all from grass-fed cows.

Don’t know where your local farmer’s markets are? This is a good place to see what’s near you.

4. Buy from Whole Foods or other Natural Food stores.

In some states, retail sales of raw, grass-fed dairy is perfectly legal. In other states, your natural food stores may not carry raw grass-fed butter, but they’ll still carry grass-fed butter from a local creamery or two.

Find Grass-Fed Butter in Grocery Stores: Good Choice

This butter may not be local to you, but it is from grass-fed cows. Many of these are imported from other countries, so you may not find them on your butter aisle. Instead, they’ll be in the deli section along side specialty imported cheeses and spreads.

Here are a few popular brands of grass-fed butter available nationally.

1. Organic Valley Pasture Butter.

find-grass-fed-butter-organic-valley-pastureThis butter comes in a distinctive green package and is produced from May to September when pastures are green and lush and account for 99% of the cow’s feed. Like all Organic Valley products, it is produced without the use of antibiotics, growth hormones, or pesticides.

I am almost always able to find this year round at my local grocery store, although it’s also available for purchase online.

If you aren’t sure whether or not your local grocery store will still carry it in the winter, you can do what I did the first year I discovered it: stock up! Just buy a whole bunch of it all summer long and line your freezer shelves with it.

(where to find Organic Valley Pasture Butter online)

2. Kerrygold Butter.

find-grass-fed-butter-kerrygold-butterKerrygold butter is imported from Ireland, and their cows spend 10 months out of the year (312 days) grazing beautiful Irish pastures.

Over the past couple of weeks, I’ve received many emails from readers who are worried about Kerrygold. I know some folks are freaking out that Kerrygold cows (during the WINTER) are fed Grains of Unknown Origin. Kerrygold has responded to consumer questions and admitted that probably about 3% of the grains they feed during the winter may contain GMOs.

But, guys! This is IRELAND. In the WINTER. What do you expect? There is no rapidly growing green grass like you’d find during the spring and fall. Yes, there are options for green-feeding cows in the winter, and if you buy fresh butter from a local dairy or creamery, you can ask those farmers and find out what they do and support them if you want to.

But if you live in an area where local grass-fed dairy is hard to come by, Kerrygold is still one of the few semi-decent options for you to buy pre-made butter as many grocery stores (including giants like Costco and Trader Joe’s) carry it.

If you don’t want to support Kerrygold, despite the fact that 10 months out of the year they keep their cows on pasture and that they’re committed to humanely raising dairy cows, then there are other options for store-bought grass-fed butter.

(where to buy Kerrygold butter online)

3. Anchor Butter.

find-grass-fed-butter-anchor-butterAnchor butter is imported from New Zealand — land of reliably grass-fed lamb. It is not certified organic by the USDA, but the cows are out on pasture year round.

New Zealand has very strict regulations for its cows, so this butter is happily hormone-free, antibiotic-free, and additive-free.

I’ve seen Anchor butter in the deli section of my local grocery store (not the butter aisle), and I’ve also seen it at Whole Foods. You can also buy it online.

(where to buy Anchor butter online)

4. Allgau German Butter.

find-grass-fed-butter-allgau-german-butterLike the name implies, this grass-fed butter is imported from Germany. Like Anchor butter, it is not certified organic by the USDA, but the cows are out on pasture the majority of the year.

Unlike Kerrygold, Allgau cows do not receive grains during the winter months, instead getting 100% hay.

This grass-fed butter is also antibiotic-free, hormone-free, and additive-free. I’ve never seen Allgau in my local grocery store, but I have seen it in Whole Foods, Sprouts, and Natural Grocers.

(where to buy Allgau German Butter online)

5. Smjor Butter.

find-grass-fed-butter-smjor-icelandic-butterThis grass-fed butter is imported from Iceland. Their cows are raised with identical standards to the Allgau butter above — out on pasture most of the year, no grains during the winter but hay instead, antibiotic & hormone-free.

I’ve found it in one local natural food store, but then they stopped carrying it. I have not found it online. But, if you see it in your grocery store, you can trust it’s a great brand.

6. Humboldt Creamery Butter & Kalona Supernatural Butter.

These two grass-fed butters are produced here in the USA, but their cows receive a diet of 20% grains during the winter months. Because these brands are certified organic, however, you can trust that the grains do not contain GMOs.

I’ve found both butters at a nearby Sprouts market, and I wasn’t impressed with either. They were very white and a little flavorless. That said, I may have simply bought their winter butters (which, for all intents and purposes are no different than buying regular organic butter).

What about certified organic butter?

All butter is fabulous, and organic butter at least comes from cows raised without growth hormones or antibiotics. You also know their feed is GMO-free and pesticide-free. YAY.

Yet, organic dairy standards in the U.S. only require cows have “year round access to the outdoors except under specific conditions (inclement weather),” not necessarily that their outdoor lots be full of lush, green grasses and happy meadows and pastures.

So, while some organic dairies may raise their cows out on pasture for the vast majority of the year, others simply may not. Therefore, organic certification is completely irrelevant to determining if the butter is from grass-fed cows.

(top photo of homemade butter by devaburger)

Print Friendly
Sharing Is Rebellious! ENJOY.


The following two tabs change content below.
I am a passionate advocate for REAL FOOD -- food that's sustainable, organic, local, and traditionally-prepared according to the wisdom of our ancestors. I'm also an author and a nutrition educator. I enjoy playing in the rain, a good bottle of Caol Ila scotch, curling up with a page-turning book, sunbathing on my hammock, and watching my three children explore their world.
STANDARD FTC DISCLOSURE: In order for me to support my blogging activities, I may receive monetary compensation or other types of remuneration for my endorsement, recommendation, testimonial and/or link to any products or services from this blog. Please note that I only ever endorse products that are in alignment with Food Renegade's ideals and that I believe would be of value to my readers. You may read my full disclosure statements here.









80 Responses to Where to Find Grass-fed Butter
  1. Lindsey
    July 25, 2013 | 1:40 pm

    Azure Standard offers a beautiful yellow butter that is very inexpensive. It is Rumiano Pasture Butter, and is less than $4/lb. I have been buying this butter for the past few months, and it is the best butter we have ever had! We’ve tried KerryGold, Kalona, and Organic Valley (and they were all good, in my opinion) but this Rumiano butter beats them all in color and flavor!

    • Kristen
      July 25, 2013 | 1:49 pm

      Thanks,Lindsey! I love Rumiano cheeses.

      I’ve always intended to try Azure Standard, but have never brought myself to do it. Instead I’ve been buying in bulk through Amazon Subscribe & Save since it’s all delivered to your door. I always hear such great things about Azure and really should look into it!

      • April - Reluctant Healthwife
        July 27, 2013 | 12:58 pm

        I just picked up my 5lbs of Rumiano Pasture butter yesterday. I’ll have to compare it to the Kalona and Kerrygold and let you know how it compares. Thanks for the other options!

      • JUDITH
        July 27, 2013 | 7:32 pm

        After ordering mail order from Azure Standard for 25 years they started a new route to New Mexico a year and a half ago and the truck brings my order to the highway 1 1/2 miles from our house. I am so thrilled and only go to the city (350 mi. round trip) every 6 mo. instead of every 6 weeks.

    • Steph
      July 30, 2013 | 2:31 pm

      Wow, what a timely post!! We try and buy raw pasture butter from the Amish family we get our raw milk from, but the summer heat has really dropped the cow’s summer production down to the point that they are not able to make much butter now. I try and stock my freezer, but now we are eating into that stock, so I have been wondering where to get pasture butter from! I also order from Azure and had no idea about the Rumiano pasture butter–and for a great price too!! :) Thank you for mentioning that, it will definitely help our family out!

      • Steph
        July 30, 2013 | 2:34 pm

        I checked the Rumiano pasture butter out on the Azure Standard website and “natural flavor” is listed in the ingredient list. Has anyone checked into this?!

        • Jen
          August 1, 2013 | 3:37 pm

          I just checked the pasture butter on the Azure website, and the only ingredient listed for the unsalted butter is pasteurized cream. The salted also lists sea salt. I don’t see “natural flavor” anywhere.

          https://www.azurestandard.com/shop/product/11690//

          • Steph
            August 2, 2013 | 9:07 am

            That’s awesome!! When I checked it the other day, “natural flavor” was listed in the ingredient list. I did a google search and found others asking the same question. I am hoping that was just a listing error. Thanks for linking that!

            • Nickelle
              August 7, 2013 | 2:36 pm

              I just read an article on that saying that they switched companies who make their packaging and this was a misprint. Because the company makes packaging for several dairies and didn’t remove the “natural flavoring” from the ingredients list when making the Azure Standard packaging.

  2. LarryB
    July 25, 2013 | 2:14 pm

    Smjor is an excellent product! I first bought it in Iceland and I’m happy to be able to find it here in Seattle. (Must be our Scandinavian heritage.)

  3. Allison
    July 25, 2013 | 9:22 pm

    I find lots of different, excellent, grass-fed butters on iGourmet.com. Every few months they have a big sale and I usually get a dozen at a time along with some raw milk cheeses. Shipping charges start at about $16 — since I’ve saved that much by buying during their sales, the overall price comes to a wash. But you can add as much other of their items you might fancy without increasing the shipping fees by more than a dollar or two.

    • Danielle
      July 30, 2013 | 2:59 pm

      Thank you for referencing this site! This is the first time I have heard of it. I just checked it out and am “in love”!

  4. Dena Norton
    July 25, 2013 | 10:06 pm

    Wonderfully helpful post- thank you!

  5. Sharon Devi
    July 26, 2013 | 5:30 am

    I came across this article, where the author claims that, quote: “In August the firm that owns Anchor butter began making Anchor butter in the UK – they now use milk from UK cows so, because of our climate, the cows will NO LONGER BE GRASS-FED and out in the fields 365 days a year like the cows in NZ.” Source: http://www.housepricecrash.co.uk/forum/index.php?showtopic=186075

    And another, quote: “Anchor butter is to be produced in the UK for the first time, as brand owner Arla migrates production from New Zealand”. Source: http://www.thegrocer.co.uk/fmcg/fresh/dairy/arla-moves-anchor-butter-production-to-the-uk/232185.article

    I’m not sure how this is relevant to the US version of the Anchor butter? Or is this only affecting the UK- Anchor butter?

    • Sharon Devi
      July 26, 2013 | 11:32 am

      Why is my comments ‘censored’? I can see other people’s comments have been approved. Did I say something wrong?

      • Kristen
        July 26, 2013 | 1:27 pm

        Hi Sharon,

        All comments with two or more outbound links are automatically filtered for approval in an effort to prevent spam.

        So, it’s not censored, just ushered into a queue waiting for me to approve it and verify that you are, in fact, a real person with a real contribution to the discussion!

        Hope that helps,
        ~Kristen

    • Kristen
      July 26, 2013 | 1:28 pm

      Oh, good question! I’ll have to contact Anchor and find out.

    • Againstthegrain
      July 26, 2013 | 1:49 pm

      FYI regarding NZ Anchor butter and NZ dairy in general – earlier in 2013 I spent 4 months living in Christchurch, NZ. I thoroughly enjoyed exploring NZ food in general and dairy foods in particular, esp the lovely cheeses from Canterbury Cheese in Christchurch. I learned a lot about NZ milk and dairy at the farmers markets and CC, plus I observed the cows on pasture when we traveled outside our homebase in Christchurch.

      It’s true that cows are out primarily out on lush pastures in NZ, but personally I wouldn’t be quick to buy imported NZ butter on a regular basis because of an issue related to the massive overproduction of the NZ dairy industry.

      On the South Island in particular, the east side of the island is naturally drier than the tropical West Coast because rainfall amounts decline after moisture-laden winds blow over the North-South mountains and drop most of the moisture as rain and snow on the west slopes and mountainstops (the mountain range is like a spine down the center of the South Island). The South Island’s prime agricultural region in the east, the Canterbury Plains, has experienced drought conditions for several years, so pastures are nearly continually irrigated with aquifer water (natural underground water reservoirs) to stay green. The current rate of irrigation with aquifer water is unsustainably high and water tables are dropping. What is even more insane is that NZ’s dairy production is far higher than necessary to feed NZ, and is kept extremely high to sell the excess overseas as a cash crop. There is so much excess NZ milk production that much of it is processed into milk powder, which is more easily and cheaply shipped overseas to food processors to use as a shelf-stable and inexpensive protein source and food additive. The NZ dairy industry, even in the face of unsustainable irrigation practices during extended drought conditions, is aggressively marketing its milk powder in China, in particular, trying to convert a mostly non-milk consuming culture into milk-drinkers.

  6. Liz oke
    July 26, 2013 | 5:42 am

    Another useful article, thanks for the heads up on kerrygold and anchor butter. Personally I buy my butter from the Guernsey Dairy as they have a better milk protein than the black and white cow.

    I really want to thank you for all your work, 2 years ago I would have been eating Flora because I had fallen for their marketing, what a joy it is to slosh my beautiful yellow butter around on everything and do so knowing I am giving my family a health food. Everything tastes better with butter. Love it!! X

    • Kristen
      July 26, 2013 | 1:32 pm

      You’re welcome. I love butter, too!

  7. Jamie
    July 26, 2013 | 11:12 am

    Dear Kristen,

    Thank you for writing about Kerrygold. We are told to follow an 80/20 clean eating diet to maintain sanity. If the cows who produce our butter eat a 97/3 clean diet, I think we can give them a pass and still consider Kerrygold a healthier option than most butter found in the grocery store.

    • Kristen
      July 26, 2013 | 1:35 pm

      That’s how I feel, too. I obviously think there are BETTER options — like raw butter from a local, grass-fed dairy, and I love both the Organic Valley Pasture Butter and Smjor as my backups. (If you can find Smjor, try it! It’s soooo delicious.) But if I *need* butter and I’m in a local grocery store that doesn’t carry anything exotic, I can almost certainly count on it having Kerrygold!

  8. Againstthegrain
    July 26, 2013 | 1:51 pm

    My local (San Diego County) Whole Foods carries Smjor Icelandic butter. 250 g blocks for $3.99, sometimes on sale By One Get One Free (I stock up my freezer butter stash then).

    • Kristen
      July 26, 2013 | 2:23 pm

      It’s a rule. Whenever this or the OVPB are on sale, I *always* stock up. As in, I clear the refrigerator shelves. ;)

  9. Mikki
    July 27, 2013 | 8:27 am

    I just spent two weeks in Ireland and before and after I went contacted the Dublin WAPF chapter, which was just getting established. I wrote back and forth to the woman doing their Facebook page. She laughs at us all thinking Kerrygold is this super pure, grassfed butter. She actually orders her organic (which Kerrygold is not) butter from France! I couldn’t believe an Irish woman was getting her grassfed butter from another country! I was shocked when she sent me info, sites, videos, etc. about Ireland’s “grassfed” animals. She claims the pasture is usually not organic, not natural at all, but planted pasture with non organic rye seed and heavily sprayed with pesticides so it will grow because it is so damp there, the grass tends to rot. I guess think pete bogs? She also told me that they had such a wet Spring, the grasses rotted so, that the farmers had to have hay shipped in from…..the USA and other countries! Anyway, I was disappointed to learn this. It is a lovely sight to see cattle and sheep on pasture, but then to learn it’s planted and sprayed kind of a downer, right? Also, I learned that the distilleries and breweries actually get rid of their used grains from making beer and whiskey by selling or giving it to the farmers to feed….that’s right….their cattle! The guide doing our tour was very proud of that!! Anyway, Irish butter…..not all it’s cracked up to be! Sorry!

    • KristenM
      July 27, 2013 | 12:28 pm

      I guess this doesn’t bother me as much as it does you. I live in Texas, and raising 100% grass-fed cattle here is a lot of work. We are so hot in the summer that the natural state of pastures is to dry up and turn brown unless farmers irrigate and plant rye, oats, and barley.

      And yes, there is sometimes a minimal amount of fertilizer or pesticides sprayed on said fields to protect the ranchers investment.

      It’s often the only way to green-feed cattle during our dry months. Given that the treatments are often organic and only used minimally when necessary, I think it’s a viable solution for producing grass-fed meat and dairy.

      In other words, the benefits far outweigh any displeasure I may have at the inputs.

      Let’s be honest here. There’s a reason cattle trains and cowboys used to be a thing out west. They were following the green pastures north as the seasons changed, recreating the natural migration patterns of large ruminants like bison, fattening the cattle as they slowly followed lush, rapidly growing pastures north. Given that we no longer have open plains and instead have private, fenced in ranches, what else are our ranchers to do? They have to stay put, which means irrigation, planting fields, and sometimes treating those fields to keep them as viable feed.

      The other solution, and the one I think we agree is terrible, is to create CAFOs to fatten and finish the cattle.

      Isn’t it better to raise the cows naturally, out on green pasture, even if those pastures require inputs? We aren’t all lucky enough to live in temperate climates where grass will naturally grow and stay green with just rainfall for most of the year.

    • Gg
      July 27, 2013 | 1:46 pm

      For your information, there is absolutely nothing wrong with feeding cows the grains used to make beer for example. Hops are extremely nutritious as are barley, malted barley and rye used to make whiskey. These nutrients are then ‘gifted’ to us in the milk and butter produced. This has been common practice to boost the winter nutrition in a grass-fed cow herds diet for hundreds of years. Long before anyone had even heard of the word ‘organic’. Irish butter is excellent and you won’t find any better within Europe.
      As for New Zealand butter, it is literally the best on the planet with no exaggeration. Every cow and yes, sheep in the country is ‘grass-fed’. Other countries look to NZ for advice on how to produce and manage their own dairy because they are the recognized standard in excellence, quality and expertise. It is also the best flavoured dairy from the cleanest environment anywhere in the world. Bonus, no pollution including radiation like that which circulates around the Northern Hemisphere.
      Any brand from New Zealand you can find will be of the same quality no matter the brand because it all comes from the same supply of cows!…Delicious!

      • Honora
        July 29, 2013 | 1:32 am

        Alas, the game is changing. The NZ cows are for the most part outside, eating grass, kale and other green crops. However some herds are now being kept indoors though thankfully this is not common. Understandably there’s very little publicity about it for reasons.

        I encounter dairy farmers through the line of my work (phlebotomy) and get a chance to chat about how things are done. All our cows have electronic eartags. This enables the big milk producers to be automatically dispensed wheat up to 1 kg twice a day if they are really big producers.

        These dairying buggers also have been feeding their cows other sources of cheap fodder affecting the lipid composition. For a while the NZ dairy herd were consuming a quarter of the world’s production of palm kernel extract. Currently the dairy cheque isn’t paying so well, so the farmers have been advised to try and source domestic fodder instead of importing.

        95% of dairy production in NZ is through Fonterra. They have partnerships in palm oil production plants in Indonesia. The palm oil is cultivated on land that before this was virgin tropical rainforest populated with indigenous tribes and orangutangs. The tribes get ‘resettled’ and the orangutangs are subjected to the fires that are used to clear the land for planting palm oil trees. However, all in all, NZ butter may be the best of a bad bunch as as Gg says, we don’t get the Northern Hemisphere circulation and associated issues. But with our greedy rapacious current government we can no longer sit on our laurels.

        Here in our province, the rivers are becoming trickles due to increasing irrigation and all that cow effluent has to go somewhere. The industry is known as ‘dirty dairying’ around here. A fair percentage of dairy farms (around 30%) are non-compliant with environmental regulations e.g. fecal discharge.

    • Donal Kinsella
      December 23, 2013 | 10:23 pm

      Never heard such rubbish in my entire life , I think you need to name names so i can contact this ” Irish person ” and put her and you straight on a few facts, The grass does not and never has rotted in the ground it is because of the high rainfall that the grass is so lush for over ten months of the year , Ireland is not a bog there are bogs but cattle do not graze on them because they are protected sites,Below is a link to Kerrygold the dairy company you are trying to destroy for your own reasons please read it fully

      http://www.kerrygold.com/sustainability/#home

    • MacK
      January 23, 2014 | 7:49 am

      Nonsense – absolute nonsense. Beurre d’Isigny (which is nice by the way) is bought in Ireland because it is posh!

      Almost all dairy pasture is planted and cultivated, including organic pasture. In Ireland farmers typically plant white and red clover because they are nitrogenous plants – i.e., they generate nitrogen in their roots naturally, decreasing the need for fertilisers.

      As for disposing of spent grain from distilling and brewing – your point is? Please explain what is wrong with this spent grain?

      Good lord, what a nincompoop!

      • traci narkewicz
        January 29, 2014 | 8:15 am

        The problem is that cows were not designed to eat grain at all. This is about grass-fed butter, and grass-fed butter does not come from cows that eat grain…regardless of where that grain comes from.

  10. Anna
    July 27, 2013 | 11:20 am

    I also have heard recently that Kerrygold ain’t that grassfed (don’t have sources to back me up, though). I’ve made my own from raw cream (stopped b/c too much work picking it up way out here in the boonies from way out in *other* boonies…) and now buy Mother’s Choice from Larsen’s Creamery (Oregon) at the store. I’ve heard (again, can’t verify) that it’s grass-fed and have an email in to them about whether it’s 100% grass-fed and what kind of cows produce the milk.

    • Donal Kinsella
      December 23, 2013 | 10:47 pm

      You need to sue Kerrygold because they say on their site the cows are grass fed for ten months of the year , Sadly you have zero facts to back up anything you say so probably would not win ,

      http://www.kerrygold.com/sustainability/#home

    • James
      March 22, 2014 | 4:35 am

      I found some goo informaton from a Larsen’s creamery representative posted on this blog:

      http://www.meetup.com/WAP-and-Paleo-NW/messages/63480132/

      The Mother’s butter IS very tasty, and has that gold color.. Enjoy what we’ve got on the west coast, if that’s your thing!

  11. Baris
    July 27, 2013 | 1:50 pm

    Great post! I often buy and recommend Organic Valley Pasture Butter. My favorite is Organic Pastures Raw Butter, which is usually about $15 bucks a pound.
    These are what I often recommend but many of my client still shop at Safeway vs farmers markets, so I can at least count on Kerry Gold being available to them.

  12. Ginna Germain Basile
    July 27, 2013 | 2:17 pm

    Thanks for the info!! I still refuse to buy Kerrygold butter though!! I’ll stick to Organic Valley for now!! :-)

    • traci narkewicz
      January 29, 2014 | 8:29 am

      from the Kerrygold website:
      Cows in Ireland calve in the spring and are therefore outdoors, grazing on green grass when they are producing milk. After calving, cows are provided with supplementary feed to help restore protein and nurture them through this period.

      “The majority of our cows’ supplementary feed is locally grown crops such as wheat and barley. As a small island, Ireland does not have enough land available to grow certain crops locally; therefore a number of crops are imported. These imported crops comply fully with strict European and Irish legislative requirements on labeling and traceability.”

      So EVERY cow there is fed grain, which may or may not come from Ireland. I’m not trying to “destroy the good name of company, just trying to feed my family as healthfully as I can through due diligence.

  13. Susan
    July 27, 2013 | 2:41 pm

    Yes, helpful article! Kerrygold has a May – September green label butter as well. I found it at Sprouts and Whole Foods.

  14. Lara
    July 27, 2013 | 6:13 pm

    What about Amish butter? I’ve heard people rave about it, but I don’t know whether it’s from grass-fed cows.

    • Kristen
      July 27, 2013 | 6:28 pm

      I think that varies from farmer to farmer. I wouldn’t trust that it was grass-fed unless I *knew* the farmer, or unless it was an Amish co-op that advertised the butter as being 100% grass-fed.

  15. Nickelle
    August 7, 2013 | 2:33 pm

    Seeing as how it’s been difficult to find good, raw, pastured butter in my area I’ve been looking for a good, rich, flavorful pastured butter I can buy in stores so this is a timely post!

    When I started changing my diet some six months ago I switched from margarine (which I had always heard was healthier-and from my mom, that it tastes better and butter was “gross” and “fattening”) to Land O Lakes whipped butter. It was snow white and had no smell and a vaguely plastic flavor. In the last couple of months I switched my shopping from the regular grocer to Whole Foods and Sprouts and have picked up a different butter t each shopping the last couple of months to find something good. This past month I got Kalona butter but was unimpressed with it’s whiteness and lack of flavor, hardly better than the Land O Lakes.

    Now I’m having a hard time deciding which to try next! All I want is a good, rich, creamy butter! But depending on what I can find the Smjor, Organic Valley Pasture Butter, and Anchor all seem to have good reviews. If none of those live up to expectations I may try the Azure Standard Rumiano butter as the comments are full of great things about them. Here’s hoping I can find a good butter soon and get off the snow white, tasteless stuff I’ve been stuck with ever since changing my diet!

  16. Pamela Hannam
    August 8, 2013 | 4:11 pm

    Again, the mistake of believing that “Amish” equals sustainable/grass fed/organic, etc. Not true. If you buy from an Amish farmer or coop, you still want to confirm that their butter is from grassfed cows and, perhaps, ask what they feed their milks cows in the winter months. I am lucky to have an Amish farmer who produces excellent cream and butter from grassfed cows. When I don’t buy the butter, I buy the cream and make my own. Or I buy up extra butter and freeze it. Yum.

  17. Kaylene Rinehart
    August 8, 2013 | 5:23 pm

    My Kroger store has great organic butter- No antibiotics,added hormones,or preservatives, USDA Organic, ingredients are: Organic Pasteurized sweet cream, salt. Contains milk. Also available in unsalted. The name is “simple truth organic”. I have been buying it on sale for under $4.00 # –Yummy !

    • Rex
      August 15, 2013 | 7:58 pm

      Is the Kroger ‘simple truth organic’ butter grass fed?

  18. Nicole Sudhoff
    August 19, 2013 | 11:06 pm

    SO glad you mentioned Anchor! They actually carry this at our local Walmart, and the price is way better than Organic Valley, and it looked and tasted so much like pastured butter, I was really hoping the cows were grass fed! Hooray!

  19. Cait
    August 28, 2013 | 11:56 am

    It’s all I can do to buy organic butter ($3.99-4.99 lb) right now, but I would love to find a source for grass fed butter that is more attainable price-wise. I already reserve it solely for spreading (and we love butter!) because I can get such a good price on organic coconut oil that I use that for all other cooking and baking needs. Kerrygold and Organic Valley are available here but there’s no way I could buy them every week. I’m just thankful that the coconut oil price has helped me afford butter that’s at least free from worse toxins, being organic and hormone/GMO free, even if it’s not the superfood it could be. Someday!

    • Benson
      February 4, 2014 | 8:53 pm

      Sounds like you run through a lot of butter. I predominantly use Natural, “Real” Olive Oil for most of my cooking and oil needs. I still believe quality butter is a health food, but something that should be consumed in moderation.

      Not to digress on the subject of butter, but has anyone tried the “Real” olive oils that are becoming more popular now? 90% of store bought olive oils are fake, toxic, trash.

  20. Sonia
    September 29, 2013 | 1:44 pm

    Occasionally I can score some raw milk butter from a good dairy just over the state border – but never enough! It’s unbelievable. However recently I’ve been using Organic Valley’s cultured butter and it’s divine. Even better than Kerrygold’s I think.
    THANK YOU so much for this helpful post. I’m bookmarking it and will share with friends trying to eat better.

  21. Joseph
    September 29, 2013 | 3:47 pm
  22. Sue McEwan
    September 29, 2013 | 6:31 pm

    What I have read in the past about KerryGold butter is that it is grass fed BUT in Ireland they are still using Lindane pesticide on their pastures. Lindane has been outlawed in the US for years and that is the reason I refuse to eat KerryGold butter.

    • Donal Kinsella
      December 24, 2013 | 4:26 pm

      Hey get your facts right and STOP scaring people ,Lindane was banned in the EU on 31st December 2007 and as you know Ireland is a member of the EU (European Union ) Why do people like you talk before engaging their brain ?????
      By November 2006, the use of lindane had been banned in 52 countries and restricted in 33 others. Seventeen countries, including the US and Canada, allowed either limited agricultural or pharmaceutical use.[12] In 2009, an international ban on the use of lindane in agriculture was implemented under the Stockholm Convention on Persistent Organic Pollutants. A specific exemption allows for it to continue to be used in second-line treatments for the head lice and scabies for five more years. The production of the lindane isomers α- and β-hexachlorocyclohexane was also banned.[15] Although the US has not ratified the Convention, it has similarly banned agricultural uses while still allowing its use a second-line lice and scabies treatment.

  23. Donald
    October 21, 2013 | 3:06 pm

    I recently started buying the Humboldt Creamery butter. I thought the taste and color were incredible. On the color, it was a much deeper yellow than Clover butter. Sorry, I don’t have any of the others for comparison purposes.

  24. Sheila
    October 22, 2013 | 5:58 pm

    Girls don’t forget about pasteurization. All the butter you have men tioned. Is pasteurized. It’s like buying the dead white liquid they call milk, at the store. Dead of all the wonderful healthy live enzymes and stuff that was there before they heated it to hell! My opinion is why even try to buy raw, if it’s pasteurized? Because if it’s pasteurized, it’s NOT raw.

    • Jenn
      January 25, 2014 | 8:04 pm

      I’m not quite sure where what you’re saying has been discussed here, but I do know that sometimes people get the terms “pastured” and “pasteurized” mixed up.

      We are discussing sources of pastured (cows who graze on pastures) butter. We know it has been heated (pasteurized) but it’s the next best thing after raw, pastured/grass-fed butter and still has nutritional benefits.

      • traci narkewicz
        January 29, 2014 | 8:11 am

        I have the same question. Weston Price says “raw, grass-fed” butter. If all of this butter is pasteurized aren’t we losing most of the benefits of the butter (whether it’s grass-fed or not)? In other words, is there still a benefit to grass-fed butter if it’s been pasteurized?

  25. Tiffany
    October 25, 2013 | 8:22 pm

    I don’t have access to raw grass fed dairy where I live so the best I can find is certified organic butter that is mostly grass fed depending on weather and fed certified organic grains including corn and soy. I could however cross the borders to the States and stock up on some Kerrygold butter. Is this better than the butter I have now? I’ve heard that Kerrygold cannot guarantee that their grain feed is GMO free so i’m quite worried there as I avoid all GMOs.

  26. liz bradford
    November 1, 2013 | 4:55 am

    hi i live in southern ireland so dont have a problem getting butter most of the cows here eat silage wth grain in the winter so it is still mainly grass i strive to be self sufficient my own pigs,poultry lambs,i always know how lucky i am and thank my own god for the gifts i get.

  27. Leia
    November 17, 2013 | 1:23 am

    At one point in history Cork, Ireland was the #1 exporter of butter in the world. There is even a butter museum in the city of Cork. I’ve totally been there!

  28. Kathy
    December 15, 2013 | 11:19 am

    Humboldt creamery butter is not made with milk produced in Humboldt county, pasture based.

  29. Sófus
    December 18, 2013 | 6:00 pm
  30. Patrick
    December 28, 2013 | 1:26 am

    Awesome information, thank you very much for simplifying my search for good butter. :)

  31. Deborah Ruiz
    January 15, 2014 | 4:40 am

    What a WONDERFUL resource! I’ve spent the last 1/2hr just browsing through the links, wondering how I never knew about organic farmers within “spittin’ distance” (as we say here in NC) from my house! Looking forward to getting in contact with them within the next few days I have off!

  32. Amy
    January 22, 2014 | 8:48 am

    I live in Ireland and after doing a bit of google searching to find a good grass-fed butter, found your site. Had no idea Kerrygold was a good option, so excited about that. But I do have to comment that it is extremely rare for Ireland to have no grass, only snow. Actually, I’d say that never happens. It barely ever snows here and especially never snows enough to completely cover the fields and grass. January now and there’s loads of bright green grass out in the field behind our house!

  33. Lissa Zack LoVasco via Facebook
    February 10, 2014 | 11:20 pm

    Thanks

  34. Zane Smith via Facebook
    February 10, 2014 | 11:31 pm

    Ask Anchor if they import Palm kernel to feed cows from deforested orangutan habitat here….http://www.anchorbutter.com/ and while you’re at it ask about the loss of swimmable rivers due to farm effluent

  35. Tom Gibson via Facebook
    February 11, 2014 | 12:58 am

    Unfortunately your comment about organics show that you know nothing about organics or dairy operations. Cows cannot be allowed onto pastures when the soils are very wet because animals that heavy will destroy the soil so it doesn’t matter natural or organic. It is absurd to promote large industrialized name brands that couldn’t possibly meet the standards you are prompting then slam organics.

  36. Lina McDonnell Jakubowski via Facebook
    February 11, 2014 | 6:29 am

    Kriemhild Dairy Farms makes a FANTASTIC grass fed butter! You can find them at Trader Joe’s! http://www.kriemhilddairy.com

  37. Daun Felker Pringle via Facebook
    February 11, 2014 | 8:13 am

    Kalona is local to us, and their winter butter is blah but its what I buy when I cant find my regular pastured cultured butter. There is another small, local dairy that we can some times find very small tubs of butter.

  38. Manny Dominguez via Facebook
    February 11, 2014 | 8:19 am

    Sylvia Barriga Dominguez

  39. Nancy Weis via Facebook
    February 11, 2014 | 2:50 pm

    We buy Amish butter at Albertsons.

  40. Barry Russinof
    February 17, 2014 | 3:20 pm

    ANY bottle of Caol Ila is a good bottle!

    Thanks for the butter info; very helpful.

    Barry

  41. Bob
    March 21, 2014 | 11:22 am

    I’ve purchased Allgau German butter at my local Gross-Me-Outlet.

  42. Tina
    March 26, 2014 | 7:57 pm

    I am currently living in a state that is just starting to promote organic so I am quite new to all of this. I have a question about pasturized dairy products. Is any pasturization bad for milk and butter? The reason I ask is because I found a website called Natural by Nature and they only sell dairy. There web page explains that they use low heat (165 degrees Fahrenheit) to pasturize where commercial dairies use high heat (281 degrees Fahrenheit) to pasturize. I am confused.

  43. Keagan SophiaGrandma via Facebook
    April 7, 2014 | 7:13 pm

    Recently found Organic Valley Pasture butter. Best ever. Tastes like cream & you will want to eat it off a spoon !!!

  44. Food Renegade via Facebook
    April 7, 2014 | 7:18 pm

    Agreed, Keagan. We recently ran out of cream, so we used our stick blender to whip OVPB into our morning cup of coffee. SO GOOD. It gets good and frothy, is beautifully creamy and rich, and it tastes amazing.

  45. Keagan SophiaGrandma via Facebook
    April 7, 2014 | 7:20 pm

    Thanks so much for that tip. That sounds SO good. Do you use your stick blender often? I’m considering one.

  46. Kimberly Dickson via Facebook
    April 7, 2014 | 8:10 pm

    We order from Minerva Dairy in Ohio twice a year, enough to last 6 months at a time.

  47. Sam Stanton via Facebook
    April 7, 2014 | 8:33 pm

    I buy Kerrygold sometimes, but when I can I make butter from my raw cream or buy raw better from where I get my raw milk.

  48. Greg Miller via Facebook
    April 8, 2014 | 4:24 pm

    Ugh. Do you have a directory that isn’t run by a bunch of anti-vaccine nutjobs? I’d rather not give them the page hits.

Leave a Reply

Wanting to leave an <em>phasis on your comment?

Who Am I?

My name is Kristen Michaelis. I'm a nutrition educator, author, and mother of three. I adore hats, happy skirts, horizons full of storm clouds, the full-bodied feel of wind as I ride motorcylces, reading in my hammock, and a hearty shot of Caol Ila scotch. I'm also a rebel with a cause.
Food Renegade April Giveaway