Thanks to a recent survey by the Centers for Disease control, we finally have the numbers we need to determine the statistical safety of drinking raw milk. Turns out, raw milk really is safer than just about any other food out there — including spinach, peanut butter, and eggs. The risk of contracting an illness from contaminated raw milk is ridiculously small, particularly when you consider the amount of resources the federal government is pouring into undercover investigations of raw milk farmers, raids of buying clubs and co-ops, and creating an anti raw milk campaign.
For years, we’ve known exactly how many people in the U.S. get sick from drinking raw milk (an average of 42 per year). What’s been missing is the baseline — the number of raw milk drinkers in the U.S. In 2007, the CDC conducted a survey to determine the number of raw milk drinkers. And would you believe it? It took them until just a few months ago to make the data public! Running the numbers, it’s not hard to see why…
From a recent press release by the Weston A. Price Foundation:
“At last we have access to the numbers we need to determine the risk of consuming raw milk on a per-person basis,” says Sally Fallon Morell, president of the Weston A. Price Foundation, a non-profit nutrition education foundation that provides information on the health benefits of raw, whole milk from pastured cows.
The key figure that permits a calculation of raw milk illnesses on a per-person basis comes from a 2007 Centers for Disease Control (CDC) FoodNet survey, which found that 3.04 percent of the population consumes raw milk, or about 9.4 million people, based on the 2010 census. This number may in fact be larger in 2011 as raw milk is growing in popularity. For example, sales of raw milk increased 25 percent in California in 2010, while sales of pasteurized milk declined 3 percent.
In addition, Dr. Beals has compiled published reports of illness attributed to raw milk from 1999 to 2010. During the eleven-year period, illnesses attributed to raw milk averaged 42 per year.
“Using government figures for foodborne illness for the entire population, Dr. Beals has shown that you are about thirty-five thousand times more likely to get sick from other foods than you are from raw milk,” says Fallon Morell. “And with good management practices in small grass-based dairies offering fresh unprocessed whole milk for direct human consumption, we may be able to reduce the risk even further.”
“It is irresponsible for senior national government officials to oppose raw milk, claiming that it is inherently hazardous,” says Dr. Beals. “There is no justification for opposing the sale of raw milk or warning against its inclusion in the diets of children and adults.”
According to Pete Kennedy, president of the Farm-to-Consumer Legal Defense Fund, “Where raw milk is concerned, the FDA has an agenda apart from protecting the public health. The agency wants to restrict and discourage the sale of unprocessed dairy products. This will have the effect of denying freedom of choice.”
“Every time there is a possible connection between illness and raw milk, government officials issue dire press releases and call for bans on raw milk sales,” says Fallon Morell. “However, these numbers fail to justify the government opposition and prove what we’ve known all along, that raw milk is a safe and healthy food.”
So, there you have it! Raw milk is SAFE, and we know how to make it even SAFER. Put cows out to pasture. Let them eat rapidly growing green grasses. Keep milking facilities well-cleaned and sanitized. Use modern refrigeration and stainless steel holding tanks. Keep milk cold while transporting it. If you choose to drink raw milk, only drink this “good stuff.” Don’t drink raw milk that’s been intended for pasteurization (this usually comes from confinement dairies, and isn’t particularly healthful or clean.) It’s so simple, really!
(photo by suzieblackmon)
Mary Miller via Facebook says
All of us who grew up drinking raw milk certainly can’t be wrong!
Ben says
Well it shows that you were lucky, I grew up drinking raw milk and ended up with scarlet fever from drinking raw milk..
Matt says
You got scarlet fever – a non-food-borne illness – from drinking raw milk? Nonsense.
Melissa says
Scarlet Fever is caused by Group A Streptococcus bacteria (the same bacteria that causes Strep Throat), which CAN be transmitted through foods like raw milk, eggs, ice cream, chicken, etc. but it is more likely to be transmitted through inhalation or touch (close contact). In order for the food to be contaminated, someone who is infected must come in contact with the food. So it is possible for a person to become infected with Scarlet Fever from consuming Raw Milk products, but it is more likely that an individual would become infected at school, their workplace, etc. from an infected individual.
Peggy G. says
How was this confirmed, Ben?
Karen says
I had scarlet fever twice as a child…yes, and I lived. Fact is, I lived in New York City and had never drunk raw milk. I think you were misinformed
Kristen says
Scarlet fever from raw milk? You’re joking right? I sure hope this is a form of sarcasm!
ramani rangan says
Most of all, If the product involves an animal, i.e. a cow for raw milk. When it is time for the cow to die that it feel no fear and feel no pain.
April Miles Thornton via Facebook says
I saw this and found it quite compelling. But for some reason, people are still convinced there must be something terribly dangerous about drinking fresh milk. I happen to think there’s something terribly dangerous about consuming the majority of foods sold at my local grocery store. 🙂
Food Renegade via Facebook says
@Danika — Yes, we’ve been discussing it in a different thread below!
Danika Carter via Facebook says
Oh good 🙂
Joshua Allen Donini via Facebook says
April, I was just discussing the fact that we have in this country a thing called a “health food store.” It’s a shame that a person can’t walk into just any grocery store and come out with healthy food.
It’s amazing how much retail space is dedicated to imitation food.
A Mom in Michigan says
I completely agree. Priorities related to foods are topsy-turvy.
Beth Jurns via Facebook says
Well-timed, given the raid at Rawesome today in California.
April Miles Thornton via Facebook says
Yes, although even our health food stores often sell a lot of junk, too, unfortunately. But at least they provide many healthy foods that can’t be found at the regular grocery store. 🙂
Colette Hory via Facebook says
This is so timely! Listen up world! The government just disproved themselves. Now, if only we could get them to pay attention to common sense and actual health of the people instead of big business dollars… “thirty-five thousand times more likely to get sick from other foods than you are from raw milk”
Jenny says
It’s baffling to me that so much energy is put into keeping people from accessing raw milk when other riskier foods are given the green light. Imagine the good that energy could do if it were put in the right direction. In the mean time, every time I pick up my milk I feel like I’m negotiating an undercover drug deal.
Rachel says
Sounds good. Is the actual data released somewhere?
KristenM says
Are you speaking about the CDC survey data about the number of raw milk drinkers or the info on the raw milk illnesses? If the analysis of the rate of illnesses, etc., it will be published in the upcoming issue of Wise Traditions, and will probably be compiled online shortly after that.
Shirley Kuhn Dobbins via Facebook says
Then by George, they should step up to the plate and push for raw milk sales to be legal in the US!
melissa jent says
they won’t do that. Why? because the government is bought and paid for by lobbyist from Insurance companies and Big Pharma. Raw milk is more healthy and safer than the crap they sell in the store, including the majoority of the food. So by keeping people sick, the Big corps and Big Pharma keep lining their pockets. There is no money to be made in keeping people healthy. The sad thing is that now they have the doctors in their pockets as well. Doctors are now in the profession of Sick Care not Health Care. Docs literally get bonusses from Big Pharma and Insurance companies for pushing their toxic drugs on their patients. Docs don’t listen, they don’t run tests, they just pick from their cocktail of pills t hey have been given by the pharmacutical companies and when they meet their quota, Big Pharma rewqards the doctors with monetary kickbacks and elaborate trips to exotic places. Next time you go to the docs office, ask the nurse that checks you in if the pharmaceutical companies bring them big lunches on a regular basis. I know the answer is yes, because I’ve seen it time and time again while working for several medical doctors. My advice to anyone and everyone, take a proactive stance in your own health care, learn to read lab results, look for natural alternatives instead of prescription meds, they are out there. Prescription medications come with some hefty adverse reactions, including death. I’ll take my chances with plant based meds any day. I take 0 scripts and 99.9% of my food is farm to table, the rest is organic or I grow and make my own using organic ingredients. Also, watch out for GMO’s, make sure if you buy fish from the store, it’s wild caught and not farm raised. If you really want to see what they do to food, watch the documentary Eating our way to exttinction. Although I don’t agree with the crap they spew about climate change and global warming, this documentary dives pretty deep into the food, especially meat, dairy and fish, that is put in the stores.
Peg Danek via Facebook says
don’t forget the current contamination of ground turkey meat
Melissa Jane Arana Carey via Facebook says
Awesome. I was just looking for this info today! Thanks for posting.
Melissa Jane Arana Carey via Facebook says
Does anyone know where we can get our hands on the gvt reports. Are they all from CDC? Thank you!!!
Dave, RN says
Oh no. And now this:
https://www.foodrenegade.com/rawsome-foods-raided-again-by-swat/
They just won’t leave us alone.
Colleen says
If they really want to do some research, they ought to follow 2 groups of kids/adults, one drinking raw milk and one drinking the toxic garbage Big Ag calls “milk”. Let’s evaluate each group’s health, how many times they go to the doctor/get sick, health of teeth, etc. THAT would be the true test of which “milk” is really safe!
Jason says
Awesome to hear that they actually said is ok for folks! What a confusing(errr confused) organization the USDA is…
Jessica says
I’m assuming you all know the risks of consuming raw milk during pregnancy. One of the saddest funerals of my life was a infant miscarried at 6 months with a Listeria infection directly transmitted through raw milk.
Tom M Culhane says
Actually, raw milk is probably the safest thing a woman can consume during pregnancy. People, seek out raw milk drinkers and listen to their testimonials, no tooth decay, never been to a doctor, great health, so many diseases healed. You do not absorb the minerals with pasteurized, the real world evidence shows this. I highly doubt this listeria story is true, but even if it’s one of the 42, balance that against the millions with health benefits, lives saved…
Chris and Christi says
We have our own milking goats and love the freedom of being able to enjoy fresh raw,naturally homogenized milk from these animals. We can only hope that our government will see eye to eye on the truth of the safety in digesting raw milk from cows and goats.
Chris @ Earth Friendly Goodies says
It is really sad that they had to put so much effort into determining if it is safe or not – I mean 42 people get sick a year? That’s pathetic. Too bad they didn’t have a study that showed how many people get sick from the stuff they call milk in the supermarket.
Naomi Devlin says
So good to hear it verified! I never got sick drinking raw milk and spooning raw cream onto my carrots.
However, I and my son got a weird rash of pimples after drinking raw goats milk from a friend. When I looked into it I reached the conclusion that her hygiene wasn’t excellent and that the goats may have been staph carriers, as our rash looked awfully staphyloccocal. This bears out the fact that raw dairies need to be scrupulous about hygiene – as we were in the old days before all those nasty antimicrobal sprays!
x x x
Http://primaltoad.com says
Is the government ever right with their actions? Seriously?! I don’t drink raw milk as I don’t do dairy outside of butter and whey here and there. But, these stats are great news!
Kelly B says
Thanks to “jane” who posted a comment in the Anchorage Daily news i found your site! http://www.adn.com/2011/08/12/2012894/know-the-risks-before-drinking.html
Yes, I do like it (my milk) raw! We (our fam) also like as much local Alaska grown food we can eat, grow, share. We also shop @ Safeway, Fred Meyer, Costco, and try to make the best choices. having that choice is most important.
Karen Joy says
I am sorry for those who have had poor — or even tragic — experiences with raw milk. However, I find the anecdotal anti-raw-milk comments irrelevant. What we raw-milk proponents are NOT saying is that there is ZERO risk — there are 42 cases yearly of poisoning from contaminated raw milk — we’re saying that the risk is INFINITESIMAL compared to other food-borne illnesses. It’s sad that a few can have a terrible experience with something and the bad word spreads like wildfire. But what these numbers are saying is that, in spite of the few reports of illness from raw milk, the RISK is extremely low.
Tom M Culhane says
Unfortunately the govt has been slandering raw milk for a long long time. The pharmaceutical cartel makes billions off a sickly, demineralized population. Raw milk would heal so many. I doubt the “tragic” stories here are genuine. Out in the real world I only hear good things about it. It IS accurate to say there’s no risk, because it reduces the risk of serious illness and miscarriage, ie drinking it is safer than not drinking it.
Jennifer says
Specious logic. The risk is extremely low because the number of people who produce/use it is relatively low and because people a) don’t always go to the doctor for food poisoning and b) sorry but not every doctor is the Perry Mason of doctors. Unless you are grievously ill, your doctor is not taking a food history and combing your kitchen for samples to test.
Back when mostly no one had cars, no doubt there was crowing about how much safer cars are than horses. Don’t you love your kids? Why, look at how many people get thrown by a horse or trampled or kicked every year, compared to only five people last year that died in a car!
Now the tables have turned and riding a horse is much safer than riding a car. But that is not summarily because of an actual difference in risk. It’s because the number of cars used for daily transport vastly outnumbers horses being used thusly.
If you are honest you know that ’47 people got sick’ between x and y is not a truthful number. Just like the numbers for how many got sick off of ‘regular food’ is inaccurate. Just like the data on how many people got raped last year is not real. More people get sick or sexually assaulted than report it. If you don’t know that, well, now you do.
I have never seen a doctor for acute food-borne illness. Only twice have I really been in a bad way. Once was twenty years ago when I spent the night by the toilet with pillow and blanket because it was easier than running in there every twenty minutes. At one point i actually thought I might die. Hard to quantify, but I thought well, I might be on the way out. Passed out but still alive the next day…I was maybe fourteen.But the only other time anything remotely like that happened was in the past few months…after drinking raw milk. Is it sheer coincidence? Yeah, maybe. But I’ve been fine for twenty plus years, had raw milk before, and the first time I buy from a different source I wind up pitching camp in the loo? I think not. Logic tells me I am not one of 47, I’m one of many who didn’t go to a doctor.
Honestly, to say you hold the anecdotal experience of anyone who didn’t have a FAB experience ‘irrelevant’ is terrible. If you are willing to use anecdotal experience telling people how wonderful something can be, its dishonest to say only anecdotes which support you are allowed to be real. Saying simply because x hasn’t happened to you, it could not possibly be relevant or factual is just scary. Anecdotally castor oil soothes my joint aches but if someone says it didn’t help them, I’m not assuming they’re in the pay of GSK and lying for thirty pieces of silver. Likewise, if Kelly says our mutual acquaintance Wally raped her, the fact that I have yet to be personally assaulted by Wally is not proof that Kelly lied.
You go to some trouble to point out that well, you’re not saying there’s NO risk, it’s just the risk is so small that it’s fine. But not everyone who has a bad experience is ‘anti raw milk’ and people who are against it are not necessarily against it no matter what programs that could be put in place to comfort them.
I’m not ‘anti raw milk’. I still use it. I recommend others look into it. I think it should be legal in all fifty states and legal to sell off-site. I’d love to not have to drive an hour and fifteen minutes each way when I want some. But it CAN be dangerous like any food and the risk is only small because it is a small potatoes industry so far. No ones died from ‘vaping’ yet that I know of but I think we all know…’anecdotally’…that’s because it’s a minority share of the smoking market and someday they’ll figure out e-cigs are risky too.
It can be dangerous partially because it’s such an underground, rinky-dink industry. I agree people should ‘know their farmer’. But even if you have dinner and your kids play with his kids, does that make you or him an expert on germ theory? Does it give you microscopes for eyes, mutant powers of perception? Maybe some proponents will tell you raw can do that for you too. You know, anecdotally.
What middle-ground people are in favor of is having raw milk be legal but not the way it is now. If it weren’t so counterculture to farm this way, maybe dairymen could get loans with less hassle to invest in their farm. Perhaps there could be a program HE wouldn’t have to pay for to test more parts of more batches more often, and have more time for one-on-one training and supervision. If consumers can be soothed by ‘(insert your state)tested it, it’s fine, here’s a label on the side about caring for it, how long you should keep it, etc, then more people will try and be sold.
‘ people, raw milk is fine if it’s clean and the cow is healthy and x and y and z’. That is true. I’m totally behind that. People deserve to be able to trust though that that is the case without personally swabbing the tank and the udders. Clearly people deserve that from Big Food and don’t receive it all the time either. But it doesn’t win to use the ol’ well-he-did-worse-yesterday-so-what-are-you-yelling-at-me-for chestnut.
‘Trust but verify’ as Reagan said, which is one of maybe three useful things he said. The farm I went to missed the boat on at least one batch. If we nag legislators into devoting more $to food that doesn’t involve taking $ from lobbyists, they could test more products of ALL kinds ( as in not just raw) and provide more monitoring of whether animals are being treated kindly and healthfully so as to prevent situations to start with.
Theresa Weldon says
Bottom line – even the anti-raw milk site Realrawmilkfacts.com data shows there are 8 deaths from PASTEURIZED Milk products verses 2 deaths from RAW milk products.
http://www.realrawmilkfacts.com/raw-milk-news/story/updated-raw-milk-outbreak-tables/
Peggy G. says
Unfortunately, the only illnesses that are counted tend to be those that cause digestive symptoms. There is no solid data on things like allergies and autoimmune problems caused by pasteurized milk, caused by the immune system’s reaction to the dead bacterial protein that is left in the milk from heating. I have celiac disease and thought that it was good enough to drink homemade kefir made from the best local, organic, grass-fed, but lightly pasteurized milk I could find. It gave me significant sinus congestion and digestive symptoms. After switching to raw milk? The kefir not only causes no sinus congestion, it clear my sinuses if they are congested from something else. And my tummy is calm and happy. My hubby says he will never go back to drinking pasteurized.
Dellaina says
Do you have a link to the CDC study? I would love to share all this wonderful information about raw milk (we’ve been drinking it for years!) but all I’m finding at the CDC website is a bunch of negativity:
http://www.cdc.gov/foodsafety/rawmilk/nonpasteurized-outbreaks.html
Cassie Powell says
The risk IS low..until you contract a deadly pathogen from raw milk…as my five year old daughter did and who is now on her 12th day in the hospital with e.coli/HUS. She is receiving dialysis bc her kidneys are shut down. Now its personal and being one of those 42 per year is catastrophic for our family and we are fearful of raw milk. We are in Knoxville, TN.
Connie Nour Hinkle via Facebook says
Abso-freaking-lootley!
Diona Fredo via Facebook says
Yes ma’am! Whole family does!
Christie Blunted Viewz via Facebook says
That’s just nasty. I wont be able to keep you in my list anymore. Good Luck w your cow obsession!
Darcie Mayo via Facebook says
Every day. Even my immune compromised son does..my husband hasn’t been able to drink milk his whole life but now can.. 9 dollars a gallon is tough sometimes but we just do it
Tika Wolff via Facebook says
I can’t drink the processed stuff, it has to be organic or raw or else my stomache kills me
Colleen Dixon via Facebook says
You bet!
Katie Noelle via Facebook says
No, its illegal in my state 🙁
Sara Turner via Facebook says
I switched from the store bought milk to local, raw milk and my nasal congestion — which I deal with 95% of the time — disappeared. I’m sold!
Jill Herron Chapin via Facebook says
I do, I do! I buy raw goat milk from a family that raises their own food.
Laura Jones via Facebook says
Yep!
Jessica Walker via Facebook says
Yes, from our own goats 🙂
Shipley Marmion via Facebook says
Yep!
Linda Torgrimson via Facebook says
Yes!
Mary Light via Facebook says
I have used raw dairy over the years and always felt it was very superior to anything commercial, and healthy and safe.
Rich Hurd via Facebook says
When I can get it, yes. It’s far superior to the crap you get from the stupormarket.
Tamara Repsold Schwartz via Facebook says
Yes it’s delicious AND far superior to store bought. The fact that it’s illegal hasn’t stopped me. You can still get it.
Sara Schechla via Facebook says
Yep! Happy to live in legal state! (WA) Pride & Joy Dairy for us, 100% organic & 100% grass fed!!
Corrine Galle via Facebook says
Betsy Frodermann Sandra Fraser Maurer hooray!!!
CustomTattoo TheRick via Facebook says
so maybe the fed will stop wasting money screwing with people out it.
Mari Morgan via Facebook says
Yup. Got a big mug of iced decaf chai latte with Brookford Farm milk right next to me.
Julie Parcells via Facebook says
I wish Marylanders could purchase raw milk!!
Holly Merrick via Facebook says
Leo Pagliei
Cindy Newman via Facebook says
Switched to raw milk years ago. It’s delicious!
Michelle Stanger via Facebook says
only from my own cow.
Crystal Moore via Facebook says
When I had a connection that made the regular trip down to nearly Waco to pick up… unfortunately it’s not all that easy in Texas. ><
Cheri Bollendorf via Facebook says
We drink it & I make kefir from it daily here in Amish country. 🙂
Yase Benche via Facebook says
raw cow milk is good for baby cows, raw goat milk is good for baby goats. No animal’s milk is good for humans, nature just didn’t plan it that way.
Leo Pagliei via Facebook says
I have my own cow…but she is a very angry cow. She is so angry I named her Mad-dy. What about my mad cow Holly Merrick
Renee Slattery via Facebook says
We have a right to buy raw milk and juice in stores. There are a lot more deadly things in the stores like Tylenol and alcohol. If the government keeps going we won’t be able to buy fresh produce or meat anymore because of the “risks.” It’s crazy. Why don’t they just label it as risky and let us make the decision.
Irmtraud Kemmeter via Facebook says
I grew up with drinking raw milk! …and still eat raw milk cheeses!
Trish Truitt via Facebook says
Yes and Yum!
Teije Brands via Facebook says
milk is for babies, sorry
Karis Post via Facebook says
I would if I I didn’t have to drive 35 miles to get it ….
Melissa Beverly VanNort via Facebook says
Exclusively!
Marcia Bresson via Facebook says
The laws against it make no sense to me. Yes, there might be certain people who should be careful. But there are people who are allergic to peanuts, and they aren’t illegal. There are people who should not eat raw foods because they are getting chemo, and those foods aren’t illegal. Why are all of us banned from getting something because a small group of people might not tolerate it well? Why can’t that small group be warned and the rest of us be free to eat/drink what we want?
Amanda Perron via Facebook says
Heck yes!
Ashley Aselton via Facebook says
I ♡ my raw milk!
Laura Wheeler via Facebook says
So the real question here is, how many people per year are getting sick from PASTEURIZED milk? And how do the percentages compare? I’d stake money on raw being safer, because of opportunistic contamination in processing facilities AFTER Pasteurization, in which case the milk has no natural defense left, and the nasties just run rampant.
Evelyn Heikens via Facebook says
My parents drank it for years. Would take it from the barn every day to drink and use. My dad was 88 when he passed away and my mom was 92 1/2
Trish Truitt via Facebook says
Cheers (clink from a glass of tall raw.)
Rachel McElroy via Facebook says
I never thought I’d say this, but YES. I’ll never go back to the pasteurized/homogenized stuff, even if it’s organic.
Leslie Strobel via Facebook says
So maybe now the government will stop raiding small dairy farms!
A Smaller Footprint via Facebook says
WE cannot get raw milk here in Northern Ireland. I have manages to find one supplier that has non-homogenised milk but it is still pasteurized. I only drink enough for one cup of coffee a day so not too concerned.
Lula Forest via Facebook says
I can’t drink milk anymore makes me so sick….wonder if I can drink raw milk.
Cheri Bollendorf via Facebook says
Our family drinks only raw milk everyday in the form of kefir, including our German Shepherd. <3
Alex Koski via Facebook says
If raw milk could be safety removed from a cow by hand and not by machine…I would totally do it.
Christina Beisel via Facebook says
It’s not really a victory if politicians won’t read it. This was documented in our fight for raw milk legislation in Montana last year but didn’t change the FDA’s stance that raw milk is dangerous.
Christina Beisel via Facebook says
It’s not really a victory if politicians won’t read it. This was documented in our fight for raw milk legislation in Montana last year but didn’t change the FDA’s stance that raw milk is dangerous.
Simi Amiet via Facebook says
really, not long ago they were charging people who carried it over state lines… how ridiculous…
Liberty Belle via Facebook says
Will they tell the FDA to stop raiding farms that sell it now?
Carla Printz via Facebook says
I grew up on raw milk and nobody got sick
Alexandra Loureiro via Facebook says
Grew up on raw milk
Alison Westermann via Facebook says
Julia Westermann 🙂
Julia Westermann via Facebook says
Yay!!
Holly Merrick via Facebook says
Leo Pagliei 🙂
Yase Benche via Facebook says
Why the hell would any adolescent person drink other animal’s baby food, no matter if it’s raw or pasteurized.
Leo Pagliei via Facebook says
Just a thought Holly Merrick, but if it’s safe, why do we pasteurize and homogenize?
Anne Sowles via Facebook says
Sharing to read later
Mandy Lee via Facebook says
Thanks for sharing!
Rick Dove via Facebook says
Leo, the advent of filthy , chemical laden, factory farms hell bent on making huge profits at all costs , is the reason for pasteurizing, and homogenizing raw milk!!!
Sha Java via Facebook says
am i crazy or is this article 3 years old?
Tricia Shaffer Martinez via Facebook says
Er, so why do I get food poisoning EVERY time I have anything other than cheese that is made with raw milk (no matter the source)? I tried to use raw milk for about a year, and tried many different sources! Obviously there are some bacteria in it that can make us sick. We are so so lucky to live in a world that has pasteurization for foods like milk. I am so grateful.
Brandis L Roush via Facebook says
homogenization has absolutely nothing to do with health, for starters. It is done purely for aesthetics. And pasturization only became necessary when cows were brought into cities, where they didn’t have enough space and were conditions were highly unsanitary (this isn’t an issue anymore, but now CAFO’s are). Milk raised the right way, on pasture, and handled correctly is perfectly safe to drink raw.
Goldie Sunny Reilly via Facebook says
About time.
Ellie A. Akers via Facebook says
This came out YEARS ago. This is an old article not sure why it is being treated like a new one.
A. NORDYKE says
So much rhetoric here… seems like I’ve heard it all somewhere before. Unless you’ve experienced the grave illness of your own small child and watched them fight to live… because YOU spent $7.50 a gallon (for the raw milk you were led to believe – by the same language repeated here – was perfectly safe for your family) and proudly filled their little sippy cup with that creamy milk… you really cannot speak with any authority. You can spout numbers, sure. But let it be your toddler or your first grader … (Am I making some of you a little uneasy and unsure if you should put that milk on the table tomorrow morning? I hope so.) You’d never let it cross your doorstep again, and you know it. Tom Colgate – you accused me of fabricating my story because I used a phrase you’d heard spoken before. (I said I was forever changed.) So now it’s my turn to point out a term you raw milk folks like to use. You like to say that we are “slandering” raw milk. Well, to quote my favorite line from the Princess Bride (ha!) … “You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.” Google says the definition of slander, as a verb, is to “make false and damaging statements about (someone)”… So you see, one cannot slander an inanimate object. Regardless, I’m sure you must have been paid by the raw milk movement to say that because my local raw milk advocates said the same thing.
42 is TOO many, people!!! We’re not talking your run-of-the-mill food poisoning here. We’re talking life-threatening illness complete with organ failure. Go read my post on Food Safety News if you’d like to know how contaminated raw milk affected my family (unless, like Tom, you really believe government agents snuck in and sabotaged our milk jars… then I guess our story would be irrelevant to you).
Michelle says
I was considering buying some raw milk and I was researching to see of the risks outweigh the benefits. I’m not sure when this article was originally written but the CDC states that FAR more than 42 per year. According to the CDC there were 2384 illnesses between 1998 and 2011. This averages to about 183 illnesses per year. http://www.cdc.gov/foodsafety/rawmilk/raw-milk-questions-and-answers.html#risks
Can you clarify where you get your numbers from?
Thank you!
Seth says
Where is the link to the CDC data that shows this?
Nathan says
If you want a really good review and discussion of raw vs pasteurized look no further than this review article published by Johns’s Hopkins School of Public Health. If you read nothing else please look at pages 18 and 19. In the end it is a risk vs benefit discussion and I agree with their conclusion that the risk of raw outweigh the benefits in the end. Just because you personnally have never gotten sick from raw milk does not make it safe.. That’s not science or public health. http://www.jhsph.edu/research/centers-and-institutes/johns-hopkins-center-for-a-livable-future/_pdf/research/clf_reports/RawMilkMDJohnsHopkinsReport2014_1208_.pdf
Eat Like You Love Yourself says
Raw milk isn’t safe every time. Sometimes the bacterial counts are low, sometimes they’re not. Sometimes the raw milk contains pathogens, sometimes you’re lucky and they don’t. There is no step which prevents infection unless you heat it. No washing step which can remove the contamination. There is nothing you can do to ensure you are drinking milk which is ok not milk which is dangerous.
Kristen says
Raw milk is dense with nutrition, enzymes, vitamins, minerals. It’s an excellent food, and actually is a superfood, unlike some of the other foods that claim to be “superfoods”. The problem is, nobody should be telling anybody what they can or can’t eat.
Emanuel Kostrzewa says
Hi, I would like to give a thank you for the article. I posted it on my social profiles and got a great response. I look forward to more posts.
Anna Cesnjevar says
You are about thirty-five thousand times more likely to get sick from other foods than you are from raw milk,” says Fallon Morell. “And with good management practices in small grass-based dairies offering fresh unprocessed whole milk for direct human consumption, we may be able to reduce the risk even further.Every time there is a possible connection between illness and raw milk, government officials issue dire press releases and call for bans on raw milk sales.
Voy says
One question: who is the “Dr. Beals”? And you can conclude raw milk is safe by only providing ONE data from CDC (which is even not shown here)?
Calvin says
I just read the CDC rrport and it says you are 150 times more at risk with raw vrs pasteurized milk.
Tim B. says
I am reading the CDC report for studies analyzed from 2007-2012 where they found that over that 5 year period there were 979 illnesses caused by raw milk which equals 196 per year, not 42, and that is just from the 26 states which cooperated with provided reports, not 50 states. Myself, I am not frightened of drinking milk which has simply been boiled. I cook milk all the time. Cocoa. Warm milk at bedtime. Nothing to be scared of. And enough nutrients are still there, especially since I eat a whole lot more things all day than just milk. Let’s not go overboard. It’s not like the milk is being treated with chemicals. It’s just cooked. Like meat. I don’t eat raw meat either. You can, if you want. I guess what you are saying is that you want the freedom to die from raw milk if you choose to. But I think about innocent children who get sick and die because they have parents who prefer unsafe bacteria to a little bit of heat.